Posts Tagged ‘Teddy Roosevelt’s Elkhorn Ranch’

h1

TEDDY ROSSEVELT’S GOLDEN POND

June 12, 2012

Is there a way to find a win-win in this very complex scenario? 

As I read the STRIB article Sunday, my immediate reaction was YES! Make it a national monument to Teddy Roosevelt to commemorate his role in establishing our National Park system….and get it moving so it can become a part of the NPS 100th Anniversary in 2016.

But as I read on, it became an increasingly complex situation…with oil wells pumping crude there for decades; the government purchase that did not include the rights to oil and minerals below the surface ; a second government turndown to purchase at a later date; the plan for gravel pit to supply needed  gravel for new roads to support the oil boom (and employment); and an in-process evaluation of that permit request to determine project effect on air quality, water quality, and wildlife-not to speak of noise and dust.  And then an additional wrinkle of its impact on a proposed $15 million bridge over the Little Missouri to connect two highways and cut off 100 miles of travel off some commutes – also in the midst of a developing environmental impact statement regarding various crossing locations near the ranch.

 All this, but there is no mention of impact/ thoughts from the residents – indigenous people,  the whites and other immigrants that settled, and call the area their home.

By the end of the article, it seemed pretty obvious, there was no RIGHT answer.  There are issues/advantages and rights on all sides of the dilemma…and most likely, a lot of emotion on all points. 

A lesson, I guess, for those like me that have strong opinions on many topics…this situation is a great illustration that there often is no single RIGHT solution for issues we face in our complex world….and yet,  it is  one  more example that arguing right vs wrong will not work and why we as a people need to hone our collaboration skills to learn from each other and craft new ways going forward.